Pictures of Growth Strategy Team, Briana, Ebony, and Justin
Blue label titled blog post

Why the 2x2x2 onboarding strategy is failing banks and credit unions—and what to do instead

Published: May 1, 2025

Image of Pinwheel's consumer banking 2025 report

Banks and credit unions are investing heavily in acquiring new account holders—but too often, that investment goes to waste.

The reason? A legacy onboarding strategy known as 2x2x2. It worked (sort of) in the past, but in today’s digital world, it’s creating more churn than connection. New customers or members are left confused, unsupported, and often inactive. The result: low product adoption, higher attrition, and lost revenue.

Let’s break it down.

What 2x2x2 looks like in the real world

This strategy aims to engage new account openers on a delayed timeline:

Two days after account opening

A phone call, a basic email, or a letter arrives—often generic, sometimes missed altogether.

Two weeks later

Another touchpoint, perhaps nudging enrollment in digital banking or eStatements. But by now, the initial excitement is gone.

Two months after opening

A final attempt to re-engage, which often feels irrelevant or too little, too late.

Meanwhile, the customer or member is left to figure things out on their own, leading to:

You’re making a first impression—and it’s not a good one

You only get one shot at a first impression. And in financial services, that first moment has long-term consequences.

First impressions shape how customers or members feel about every future interaction. Psychologists call it the primacy effect—people form lasting opinions based on early experiences, and those impressions are hard to undo. If the first thing a new customer or member gets from you is a generic email, a paper mailer, or a delayed phone call, their perception is set: this experience won’t be easy or modern.

‍That’s a huge missed opportunity—especially when you’re trying to promote innovative features like mobile banking, Zelle, card controls, or early pay.

If you’re relying on paper to introduce digital services, you’re sending mixed signals. It’s hard to convince someone you’re innovative when your onboarding feels like it came from 2005.

Other industries understand this—and set the bar high.

These companies know: the first touchpoint isn’t a formality—it’s a strategic moment that defines the entire relationship.

It’s time for financial institutions to treat it that way, too.

Institutions are spending money to lose money

The onboarding problem isn’t just about poor experience—it’s about poor economics.

Banks and credit unions are spending real money to acquire new account holders through marketing campaigns, incentives, branch staff time, and digital ads. But when those accounts don’t activate, that investment becomes a sunk cost.

Worse yet, many of those inactive accounts remain on the books, incurring servicing costs—statements, systems, support—without generating revenue. That means institutions aren’t just losing the opportunity to grow. They’re spending money to lose money.

It’s a fundamentally broken model:

High acquisition cost → No activation → Ongoing servicing cost → Negative ROI

This isn’t just inefficient—it’s unsustainable.

Why traditional tactics aren’t cutting it

Let’s be honest—phone calls, generic emails, and printed mailers don’t match the pace or expectations of modern consumers or members. They’re not just ineffective—they’re expensive and hard to scale.

The 2x2x2 strategy treats onboarding like a checkbox exercise when it should be a dynamic, guided journey.

What banks and credit unions should do instead

To drive real activation and loyalty, institutions need to shift from static timelines to personalized, automated, digital-first onboarding. Forward-thinking platforms like Digital Onboarding show how it’s done:

✅ Engage immediately

Don’t wait two days. Trigger a welcome email or text the moment the account is opened. Include direct links to set up digital banking, order a debit card, or enroll in eStatements—before they even leave the branch or website.

✅ Guide with purpose

Replace scattered touchpoints with a step-by-step onboarding hub. Think interactive checklists, progress tracking, and personalized paths based on account type and user behavior.

✅ Automate behavior-based nudges

New customers or members procrastinate. They’re busy. They intend to enroll in digital banking or switch over their direct deposit—but it often gets pushed down the to-do list. That’s why you need consistent, behavior-based nudges. If someone hasn’t funded their account within 48 hours, send a reminder. If they’ve enrolled in mobile banking but not bill pay, suggest the next best action. The first 90 days are critical—if someone doesn’t adopt your services in that window, they probably never will.

✅ Scale without sacrificing personalization

With automation, you can deliver tailored experiences to tens of thousands of users without adding headcount. That means lower costs, greater reach, and more impact.

✅ Track what moves the needle

Smart platforms give you visibility into what drives engagement. See who’s completing onboarding steps, which messages convert, and where drop-off happens—then optimize in real-time.

✅ Deliver self-service enrollment tools that remove friction

Don’t make new customers or members work harder than they need to. Replace outdated PDFs and allow them to enroll in direct deposit in seconds. Let them opt into eStatements with an eSignature—no login required. If they forgot their account number and can’t access digital banking, help them retrieve it securely online. Don’t make them visit a branch or wait for something in the mail. Friction kills engagement—and profits. Don’t just tell account openers what to do. Give them tools that make it easy to do it.

✅ Reinforce value early and often

Don’t assume customers or members remember why they opened an account with you. Use onboarding to remind them of the value you offer—early direct deposit, cashback rewards, overdraft protection, or 24/7 mobile support. Bring those benefits to life with visuals, testimonials, or short videos that make the value tangible. When people understand what they gain, they’re more likely to stick around—and engage.

It’s time to leave 2x2x2 behind

Today’s customers and members expect more than a call in two days and a follow-up in two months. They expect fast, intuitive, and personalized digital experiences—just like the apps they use every day.

It’s time to stop thinking about onboarding as a post-sale formality and start treating it as a growth engine.

Banks and credit unions that make the shift are seeing higher activation, stronger engagement, and better retention. Those that don’t? They’ll keep wondering why their new accounts go dark—and their acquisition budgets don’t pay off.

Want to build a smarter onboarding experience?

Start by ditching the 2x2x2—and delivering the digital journey your customers and members deserve. That’s where Digital Onboarding comes in. Let's talk.